How Apple may repair its terrible Magic Mouse

Apple likes to place itself as a daring and revolutionary firm, and typically, that is true. Even within the post-Jobs period, we have seen merchandise just like the Apple Watch and the Vision Pro wield an outsized affect. The Imaginative and prescient Professional will not be flying off the cabinets because of its absurd $3,500 pricetag, however firms like Meta and Bigscreen are however adapting their very own VR headsets to really feel extra like Apple’s.

At different instances, the corporate stubbornly clings to merchandise and concepts that everybody else acknowledges as horrible. Contemplate Lightning, which it refused to jettison on iPhones till lengthy after different cellphone makers had switched to USB-C. We would in all probability be seeing Lightning on some merchandise immediately if European laws hadn’t compelled Apple’s hand. If you’ve been regulated into utilizing higher requirements, one thing’s unsuitable.

The Magic Mouse is one other instance of this angle. It has its followers, however it’s arguably one of many worst equipment Apple retains in circulation. It is not even exhausting to think about how Apple may repair the product.

Associated

Here’s why you should use Stage Manager on your iPad instead of split-screen

Your iPad can really feel much more like a Mac should you embrace Stage Supervisor.

Repair charging by making it wi-fi

Undoing one of many strangest design choices in historical past

Apple

If there’s one factor folks know in regards to the Magic Mouse, no matter whether or not they personal one, it is that its charging port is on the underside — one thing broadly thought of to be one of many weirdest and least logical design selections ever made. If its inner battery runs dry, there’s merely no approach to make use of the mouse whereas it recharges. At finest, it is an pointless inconvenience, on condition that different wired mice put their USB ports on the again, the place they belong. At worst, it may really stop you from doing all of your job until you have bought a trackpad or secondary mouse as a fallback. It is no marvel a number of Mac homeowners go straight for third-party mice.

Much more baffling is that Apple switched the product from Lightning to USB-C in 2024… and saved the charging port the place it was, regardless of loads of public criticism as much as that time. It is Exhibit A for why firms ought to hearken to buyer suggestions.

The plain design repair can be to change to a back-facing port, however since Apple loves making every part wi-fi, an alternate can be to embrace that philosophy by supporting wi-fi charging. Firms like Razer and Logitech are already placing out mice with suitable charging mats — Apple’s simply late to the get together. Heck, I might like to see a mat that doubles as a USB-C/Thunderbolt hub, although that might in all probability improve the fee to finish customers.

Associated

The 5 coolest-looking Macs you probably haven’t heard of

When you’ve solely began utilizing Macs up to now decade or so, you missed out on some wild experiments.

Repair ergonomics whilst you’re at it

Contact gestures are meaningless with out consolation

Earlier than I even discovered about its charging port, I found that the Magic Mouse is uncomfortable to carry. It is too slim for me, and since it is so flat and skinny, nearly everybody has to carry their hand in an unsupported arch, particularly in the event that they wish to make the most of contact gestures. There is a purpose most mice maintain a bulbous form — it is an acknowledgment of anatomy, not outdated aesthetics, or a have to pack in a ton of electronics. You might construct a mouse with the size of 1 / 4 if you did not have to grip it with a human hand.

Now clearly, the primary purpose the mouse is (comparatively) flat is to help these contact gestures, however there must be a extra human-friendly method. Maybe Apple may transfer contact gestures to the facet of the system, or make the shell bulbous solely the place your palm rests.

Personally, I might quite Apple exchange contact gestures with scroll wheels, however the firm appears to hate buttons and wheels nearly as a lot because it does ports. There are exceptions — we have really bought new buttons and wheels on the iPhone 16 and Apple Watch Extremely — however as a rule, Apple prefers to eradicate mechanical controls wherever contact is a risk.

Associated

Why LG’s awful Magic Remote is a dealbreaker for me

Regardless of a useful voice function, LG’s Magic Distant makes navigation and management a ache.

Assume completely different, assume efficiency

What’s a mouse for?

A part of the issue is that Apple treats the Magic Mouse as an afterthought. It is bundled with iMacs, however nothing else, and you must go looking for it should you store on the firm’s on-line or brick-and-mortar shops. At $99, it is also overpriced for its specs. For across the identical price, you will get Logitech’s MX Grasp 3S, which is taken into account a gold customary within the business. It has a number of scroll wheels, an ideal really feel, and even serves as a wonderful gaming mouse, with sensitivity settings starting from 200 to eight,000dpi. I discover something over 2,000 to be overkill — however the Magic Mouse is believed to be capped at 1,300, and would not even present you what DPI you are at when adjusting settings.

A mouse ought to by no means be handled as a minor accent. It ought to really feel that approach whenever you’re utilizing it, however solely as a result of it is meant to be a seamless bridge between you and your pc. That truly interprets into a number of work on the producer’s finish, contemplating how folks really use their units, and tailoring each final aspect to match. It is why bargain-basement mice are so horrible. You possibly can’t do every part you need, the best way you need, and their flimsy shells are a relentless bodily reminder of that.

Will Apple study its lesson and ship us a brand new, totally redesigned mouse sooner or later? Maybe. It is at the very least prone to keep within the recreation, since it could be unusual for Apple to promote Mac desktops with out a vital approach of controlling them. However there’s additionally the chance it’s going to admit defeat and go away mice to different events that care extra. That is precisely what it did with Wi-Fi routers, in spite of everything — it has been years since an AirPort product was available on the market, and few folks appear to thoughts nowadays.

Associated

4 tips for traveling safe and sound with your iPad

Do not simply seize your iPad and go, spend a while planning issues out.